Understanding Stumpages/Royalty in Native Forest

This article was printed in the Southern Queensland Forestry News magazine in Autumn 2005

Report by Ken Matthews E.O. PFSQ

The purpose of this article is to provide a better understanding of how native forest sawlog stumpage/royalty value is calculated. Additional information is then provided to assist in the interpretation of stumpage/royalty to achieve the best result for your situation.More...
 

Often a landholder is approached by one miller; they are given a price for their timber per cubic metre and then simply accept that price in the belief that is all they can achieve. In many cases this may be correct simply due to the lack of options available when marketing and selling their resource.

untitled.bmp

 Compulsory Grade Sawlog

Over the last 5 years especially, the timber industry has found it increasingly difficult to find reliable resource supplies. As a consequence the average stumpage rate and haulage distance of native sawlog has risen. Many landholders have more market options in the veneer, pole, and compulsory and salvage grades than before simply due to the fact mills are prepared to haul longer distances.
 
Sawn/graded timber has a market value that is determined by resource costs, processing costs, marketing and delivery costs and profit margin. The market price for sawn timber is influenced by competition, demand and trends. In other words, it is extremely difficult for timber wholesalers to raise the sale price, so in order to achieve a higher profit margin; sawmiller’s seek to find efficiencies and savings.
 
The basics of stumpage/royalty (The two terms have become synonymous in the private sector) is that a standing tree has a value determined by a number of factors such as species, wood quality, dimensions, distance to sawmill, quantity of resource in comparison to the scale of the property, property access and terrain i.e. rocky, steepness that impact upon cut and snig costs.
 
Once theses factors have been taken into account and cost of extraction calculated, the mill offers a price.
So the basic formula for stumpage is (Mill gate price i.e. what the mill can afford to pay for log delivered to the mill yard – extraction costs = stumpage). In other words, to a certain degree the stumpage/royalty applicable to a resource is “site specific”. It is not advisable to hear of a stumpage price achieved by one landholder and automatically assume that the same price will be applicable to your timber. The variables/constraints applicable to your property may result in either a higher price or lower price per cubic metre.
  understanding-stumpage-sawlog-picture.gif

    Salvage Grade Sawlog

One of the major mistakes made by a landholder is concentrating on the price they will receive for compulsory grade logs and underestimating the impact of a low salvage/optional grade rate per cubic metre. For example, let’s make a comparison: Mill1 offers $80/m3 for your compulsory and $25/m3 for your salvage. Mill 2 offers you $78/m3 for compulsory and $35/m3 for salvage.  Depending upon the merchandising performed by the cutter according to the mill standards and the percentage of compulsory to salvage, there can be a significant difference in the net return to the landholder                  

Rate/m3

Percentage %

Total Volume

Comp $

Salvage $

Total Value $

$80 & $25

50/50

1000m3

$ 40000

$ 12500

$ 52500

$78 & $35

50/50

1000m3

$ 39000

$ 17500

$ 56500

$80 & $25

40/60

1000m3

$ 23000

$ 15000

$ 47000

$80 & $25

60/40

1000m3

$ 48000

$ 10000

$ 58000

$78 & $35

40/60

1000m3

$ 31200

$ 21000

$ 52200

$78 & $35

60/40

1000m3

$ 46800

$ 14000

$ 60800

As you can see, for the exact same volume of timber, the percentage of compulsory and salvage grade as well as the $/m3 rate can have a significant impact upon return, i.e. From $60,000 down to $47000. Also note that even when the percentage breakdown is 50/50, there is a gain to be made by accepting a slightly lower compulsory rate and a higher salvage rate. If the cutter is merchandising the logs according to a set standard then the percentage of compulsory to salvage will be whatever is actually cut. It is not my intension to suggest that the percentage can be altered by the landholder’s opinion. However, it is my intension to suggest that an understanding of the possible log grade breakdown is important in deciding what stumpage values offered is most appropriate for you resource.  To conclude, it is also recommended that landholders consider the possibility of other product types able to be merchandised from their resource. Significant stumpage/royalty gains can be made by the recognition and segregation of products such as slice veneer billets, larger poles and even girders. 

It pays to get professional advice on product specifications and to know if these products exist within your resource.

No Comments »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

If you want to leave a feedback to this post or to some other user´s comment, simply fill out the form below.

(required)

(required)